Credit score: Unsplash/CC0 Public Area
Many New Zealand GPs have taken up the usage of AI scribes to transcribe affected person notes throughout consultations regardless of ongoing challenges with their authorized and moral oversight, knowledge safety, affected person consent, and the influence on the doctor-patient relationship, a examine led by the College of Otago, Wellington—Ōtākou Whakaihu Waka, Pōneke has discovered.
The findings have been printed within the Journal of Major Well being Care.
The researchers surveyed 197 well being suppliers working in major care in February and March of 2024, offering a snapshot in time of the usage of AI-scribes in scientific observe. A lot of the respondents have been GPs however others included nurses, nurse practitioners, rural emergency care suppliers and observe managers.
Their early experiences with AI-scribes have been blended—with customers expressing each enthusiasm and optimism, together with considerations and frustrations.
Some 40% of these surveyed reported utilizing AI scribes to take affected person notes. Solely 66% had learn the phrases and circumstances on the usage of the software program, and 59% reported in search of affected person consent.
Lead researcher Professor Angela Ballantyne, a bioethicist within the Division of Major Well being Care and Basic Follow, says AI transcription companies are being quickly taken up by major care practices, though nationwide laws and tips are nonetheless being developed.
Most of these surveyed who used AI-scribes discovered them useful, or very useful, with 47% estimating that utilizing them in each session might save between half-hour and two hours a day. A major minority, nevertheless, stated the software program didn’t save time general as a result of it took so lengthy to edit and proper AI-generated notes.
Well being professionals who responded to the survey talked about considerations in regards to the accuracy, completeness and conciseness of the affected person notes produced by AI-scribes.
One physician stated, “(It) missed some critical negative findings. This meant I didn’t trust it.” One other commented that they’d stopped utilizing AI transcriptions as a result of the ‘hallucination charge’ was fairly excessive, and infrequently fairly refined.
Others expressed concern in regards to the incapability of AI-scribes to know New Zealand accents or vocabulary and te reo Māori. One talked about pausing recordings in the event that they wanted to debate info which recognized the affected person, akin to a reputation or a date of start.
Over half of these surveyed stated utilizing an AI-scribe modified the dynamic of consultations with sufferers, as they wanted to verbalize bodily examination findings and their thought processes to permit the transcription software to seize info.
One of many GPs surveyed commented, “Today someone said, ‘I’ve got pain here,’ and pointed to the area, and so I said out loud ‘oh, pain in the right upper quadrant?'”
Professor Ballantyne says there’s a want to trace and consider the influence of AI instruments on scientific observe and affected person interactions.
These utilizing an AI-scribe felt it enabled them to focus extra on their sufferers and construct higher engagement and rapport by means of extra eye contact and energetic listening.
There was concern amongst these surveyed about whether or not the usage of an AI-scribe complied with New Zealand’s moral and authorized frameworks.
Professor Ballantyne says well being practitioners have knowledgeable and obligation to make sure their scientific notes are correct, whether or not or not they’ve used AI transcription instruments.
“They need to be vigilant about checking patient notes for accuracy. However, as many survey respondents noted, carefully checking each AI-generated clinical note eats into, and sometimes negates any time savings.”
Professor Ballantyne says it’s vital that the advantages which AI-scribes can ship are balanced in opposition to affected person rights and the necessity to guarantee knowledge safety.
“Most AI-scribes depend on worldwide cloud-based platforms (usually privately owned and managed) for processing and storing knowledge, which raises questions on the place knowledge is saved, who has entry to it, and the way it may be shielded from cyber threats.
“There are also Aotearoa-specific data governance issues that need to be recognized and resolved, particularly around Māori data sovereignty.”
In July, the Nationwide Synthetic Intelligence and Algorithm Professional Advisory Group (NAIAEAG) at Well being New Zealand—Te Whatu Ora endorsed two ambient AI-scribe instruments, Heidi Well being and iMedX, to be used by its clinicians in Aotearoa. NAIAEAG considers privateness, safety, moral and authorized points.
Professor Ballantyne says to the extent that AI instruments are novel, it can’t be assumed that sufferers consent to their use.
“Patients should be given the right to opt out of the use of AI and still access care, and adequate training and guidelines must be put in place for health providers.”
The Medical Council of New Zealand is predicted to launch steering about the usage of AI in well being later this yr, which is prone to require sufferers give consent to the usage of AI transcription instruments.
Professor Ballantyne says AI instruments are bettering over time, which can ameliorate among the moral considerations.
“Coupled with appropriate training, good governance and patient consent, the future of AI scribes holds much promise.”
Extra info:
Angela Ballantyne et al, Utilizing AI scribes in New Zealand major care consultations: an exploratory survey. Journal of Major Well being Care. (2025) DOI: 10.1071/HC25079. www.publish.csiro.au/HC/fulltext/HC25079
Supplied by
College of Otago
Quotation:
AI scribes achieve traction amongst New Zealand GPs regardless of moral and authorized considerations (2025, August 8)
retrieved 8 August 2025
from https://medicalxpress.com/information/2025-08-ai-scribes-gain-traction-zealand.html
This doc is topic to copyright. Other than any truthful dealing for the aim of personal examine or analysis, no
half could also be reproduced with out the written permission. The content material is offered for info functions solely.
