Hundreds of artists have signed an open letter calling on Christie’s to scrap an upcoming public sale of artwork created utilizing AI.
With greater than 4,000 signatories because it was printed on Saturday, February 8, the missive expressed deep issues over the public sale, titled “Augmented Intelligence,” which might be Christie’s first sale of artwork made with AI.
“These models, and the companies behind them, exploit human artists, using their work without permission or payment to build commercial AI products that compete with them,” the letter continues, including that the public sale home’s help for AI and artists who use the expertise “rewards and further incentivizes AI companies’ mass theft of human artists’ work.”
Pindar Van Arman, “Emerging Faces” (2020)
Slated to start on February 20 and run via March 5, the public sale sale will characteristic greater than 20 works spanning numerous mediums by artists together with Refik Anadol, Pindar Van Arman, AI collaborators Holly Herndon and Mat Dryhurst, OpenAI’s first Artist-in-Residence Alexander Reben, the late AARON software program creator Harold Cohen, and nameless AI collaborative artist Claire Silver. It should additionally current a choice of artists from chip producer Nvidia’s AI Artwork Gallery. Worth estimates for works vary between $10,000 and $250,000.
Idea artist Reid Southen, who organized the letter, instructed Hyperallergic that he thinks the public sale home is “doing a disservice to collectors and artists, as well as damaging their own reputation by running an auction where people can’t be certain if their purchase was built off of stolen work.”
“We think it’s reasonable to ask that the auction be halted until it can be guaranteed that everything is above board, and no one is making money off the backs of non-consenting artists via unethical models,” Southen added.
Among the many petition signatories are Karla Ortiz and Kelly McKernan, who filed a category motion lawsuit in 2023 towards 4 AI corporations for allegedly utilizing their paintings to “train” text-to-image generative AI fashions with out their consent.
On social media, the open letter has obtained blended reactions, as some digital artists together with Beeple, who offered an NFT at Christie’s for $69 million in 2021, and Jack Butcher have proven help for the artists included within the public sale by making artwork in mockery of the open letter.
“The artists represented in this sale all have strong, existing multidisciplinary art practices, some recognized in leading museum collections,” a Christie’s spokesperson mentioned, noting that the works included within the public sale “are using artificial intelligence to enhance their bodies of work.”
Harold Cohen, “Untitled (i23-3758)” (1987)
Mat Dryhurst, who has been making artwork about AI and information for nearly a decade along with his partner, Holly Herndon, instructed Hyperallergic that he feels the letter writers “[believe] AI models should be opt-in only and retrained from scratch, and that current AI models should be removed from the internet — policies that do not exist anywhere in the world. This simply will not happen, for better or worse.”
His work “Embedding Study 1 & 2 (from the xhairymutantx series)” (2024), which explores creative company and self-representation within the face of economic AI fashions, was on view in final yr’s Whitney Biennial and is included within the upcoming Christie’s public sale.
“[The signatories’] opposition to our work stems from our efforts to find a practical resolution to a complex issue — in other words, building a robust opt-out tool, which is now enshrined in law in the EU and is under consideration in the United Kingdom,” Dryhurst continued, including that “meaningful progress” requires addressing the aggressive actuality of AI coaching and {that a} “a functional universal opt-out would significantly improve the status quo.”
The letter coincides with a landmark AI Motion Summit happening in Paris this week. America and the UK refused to signal a world settlement on “inclusive and sustainable” AI expertise. Backed by 60 different international locations together with China, France, India, and Canada, the declaration pledges to make sure that AI improvement is “open, inclusive, transparent, ethical, safe, secure and trustworthy” and “sustainable for people and the planet.”
