No, the Knicks shouldn’t commerce for Jimmy Butler.
New York doesn’t want a star. The town wants ending touches.
Coming into Friday’s matchup towards the Western Convention-leading Oklahoma Metropolis Thunder, the Knicks (24-10) have established themselves as one of many NBA’s high groups. They personal the fourth-best document in all of basketball, powered by a beginning 5 that boasts one of many league’s most effective offenses.
Any transfer they make ought to deal with fine-tuning the roster, not overhauling it.
These ending touches — or the dearth thereof — will outline New York’s championship odds in an Japanese Convention dominated by two buzzsaws: the Boston Celtics and league-leading Cleveland Cavaliers.
Sure, you’ve learn accurately. The Cavaliers are that good. Kenny Atkinson has supercharged this crew past even his wildest goals.
And like New York, Cleveland, too, can be judged on postseason success, not regular-season standings.
But the Cavaliers’ edge lies of their measurement — each within the frontcourt and off the bench. The identical may be stated for groups just like the Atlanta Hawks and Houston Rockets, who’ve overwhelmed the Knicks this season by outmuscling them with versatile forwards and robust positional measurement everywhere in the ground.
The Knicks, in the meantime, lack depth in measurement. Jalen Brunson is 6-1, and whereas Josh Hart is a double-double machine, he’s simply 6-4. So is Landry Shamet, the tallest of the three guards (together with Miles McBride and Cam Payne) Tom Thibodeau likes to convey off the bench.
Which brings us again to Butler, whose profile, age, and contract standing makes him a foul match for the Knicks plans. Supersizing must be precedence No. 1 for a crew with title hopes.
It might occur internally with Mitchell Robinson’s return from a second process to restore a stress fracture in his left ankle, however selecting this route would depart the Knicks reliant on a participant with an extended latest damage historical past.
The Knicks have taken a cautious method to Robinson’s rehab, hoping this time he can keep wholesome by their playoff push.
A wholesome Robinson unlocks new lineup prospects:
Twin Towers: Robinson and Karl-Anthony Cities may play collectively, flanked by Brunson, Hart, Mikal Bridges, or OG Anunoby.
Staggered Starters: Robinson may play alongside Brunson, Hart, Bridges and Anunoby, permitting the Knicks to stagger Cities with the second unit to offer measurement and scoring. New York’s bench ranks final in factors per recreation this season.
Lock Up: With the Knicks having fun with a selection offense the place all 5 starters can hit an open three, the pairing of Robinson and Valuable Achiuwa anchor among the finest defensive lineups in all of basketball. With Robinson defending the paint, and Achiuwa, Anunoby and Bridges defending a number of positions, the Knicks ought to be capable of swiftly flip protection into offense, notably if Hart rounds out this five-man unit.
Robinson’s presence considerably reduces the Knicks’ obvious wants. However “healthy” stays the operative phrase. Thibodeau famous this week that whereas Robinson is making progress, he hasn’t but resumed full-speed operating or contact drills, placing his potential return proper up towards the Feb. 6 NBA Commerce Deadline.
That places the Knicks in a tricky spot.
They want a giant man to assist Cities and shore up their frontcourt, however Robinson’s $14.2 million wage can be troublesome to exchange with a participant equal or higher worth. Buying and selling him now can be a danger, particularly given his potential match with the crew as soon as he’s wholesome.
Different commerce choices? Achiuwa waived his no-trade clause to return to the Knicks on a one-year, $6 million deal, making him a sensible candidate. Achiuwa has supplied high quality measurement and rebounding off the bench, however his wage makes him one of many few movable items outdoors of the beginning lineup if Robinson shouldn’t be on the transfer.
McBride, who signed a three-year, $13 million extension final season, is another choice, however discovering equal worth for his manufacturing per greenback is unlikely.
Backup huge man Jericho Sims is basically outdoors the rotation and might be a straight-up commerce candidate. A possible take care of Sacramento for Alex Len, for instance, may assist bolster the Knicks’ depth at heart.
The Knicks are anticipated to be energetic on the telephones because the Feb. 6 NBA Commerce Deadline approaches. However they’ve already taken their home-run swing, and the ball is effectively on its strategy to clearing the fences.
Cities has reshaped the Knicks’ offensive identification. His dominance is mirrored in his penciled-in standing as a first-time All-Star starter in New York.
Kristian Winfield: NBA All-Star votes or win shares? Jalen Brunson is concerning the latter
In the meantime, Bridges, who struggled past perception to seek out his rhythm early within the season, has flipped the script. His latest scoring tear has not solely silenced critics however elevated the Knicks to a brand new stage of play.
The entrance workplace understands the stakes. This isn’t a crew that may agree to simply any commerce, nor will the complexities of the brand new CBA enable groups the rope to take action.
The Knicks are looking for the participant who can push them nearer to true championship rivalry. That participant might already be on the roster, recovering from damage.
Will the Knicks wait lengthy sufficient to seek out out?
WHAT ABOUT BUTLER
Butler’s time in Miami appears to be nearing its finish. He’s formally knowledgeable the entrance workplace he needs to be traded and instructed reporters in a press convention he doesn’t assume he may be completely satisfied taking part in basketball on South Seashore.
But whereas Butler has confirmed his means to guide groups deep into the playoffs, his age and contract make him a questionable match for many contenders.
The Phoenix Suns have been linked to Butler, however their commerce belongings — specifically Bradley Beal — don’t transfer the needle a lot for Miami.
A extra intriguing vacation spot might be the San Antonio Spurs. Pairing Butler with Victor Wembanyama may speed up the Spurs’ timeline, giving the younger phenom a veteran chief who thrives in high-pressure moments.
The Spurs have wiggle room in commerce negotiations.
On this situation, they ship Keldon Johnson — who averaged 22 factors per recreation in 2023 — huge man Zach Collins (or veteran huge man Harrison Barnes, although San Antonio ought to attempt to preserve him off the desk), and backup level guard Tre Jones, plus the Atlanta Hawks’ 2026 first-round decide to Miami for Butler and Alec Burks.
The Spurs have already cashed in on their first wager on veteran management: going after Chris Paul through the offseason was quietly among the finest strikes of the summer time.
Wembanyama is forward of his time, and he could be vaulting the Spurs into rivalry faster than they anticipated.
Butler to San Antonio. Who says no?
