Credit score: Pixabay/CC0 Public Area
With summer season in full swing, many individuals can be tempted by supposedly miraculous weight-reduction plan tips to lose these extra kilos that stop them from having fun with the proper physique. Amongst them are so-called “mono diets”: restrictive regimens that include completely consuming one kind of meals for a time frame, with the purpose of shortly reducing weight and “detoxing.”
In style examples embrace pineapple, apple, watermelon, peach or artichoke, in addition to grain-based choices like rice and protein-based ones resembling tuna or milk. Their attraction lies within the promise of simplicity and quick outcomes.
Fleeting weight reduction
Diets constructed on a drastic discount of calorie consumption can result in swift weight reduction. Nonetheless, consuming such a small quantity of energy means decreased blood sugar ranges. As a way to keep vitality ranges, our our bodies have mechanisms that compensate for a drop in nutrient consumption.
Initially, the physique makes use of hepatic glycogen, the principle supply of the glucose reserve that maintains blood glucose ranges, particularly between meals or when fasting. Nonetheless, as soon as this retailer is depleted, the physique begins to transform muscle mass to acquire amino acids which, via different metabolic routes, can produce glucose. This course of, sustained over time, can result in a major lack of muscle mass and different metabolic disturbances.
A lot of any sudden weight reduction is subsequently the results of a lack of water and muscle mass reasonably than physique fats, which means these outcomes are typically non permanent. When an individual returns to their standard food regimen after a strict routine, it is not uncommon for them to shortly regain any misplaced weight—this is named the “rebound effect.”
Briefly, mono diets might seem to be a fast repair, however they don’t promote sustained weight reduction, nor are they conducive to wholesome consuming habits.
Are there any advantages?
Past the preliminary weight reduction, there’s just about no scientific proof to counsel that mono diets have any actual or lasting advantages. Some folks report a sense of “lightness” or higher digestion, however these results could also be due extra to the elimination of sure processed meals than to the food regimen itself.
The “detox” ingredient of mono diets can even have a placebo impact. The assumption that they’re one way or the other cleaning their physique could make an individual really feel higher, even within the absence of any confirmed physiological modifications.
Are they harmful?
Mono diets could be very harmful, particularly if they’re extended. The principle danger is the deficiency of important vitamins, as by consuming just one kind of meals, we miss out on the proteins, wholesome fat, nutritional vitamins and minerals that the physique must operate correctly. As well as, they will result in digestive issues, metabolic problems, musculoskeletal issues, hormonal disturbances and electrolyte imbalances, particularly in folks with pre-existing well being circumstances.
One other vital hazard is the creation of an unhealthy relationship with meals, one marked by restriction and guilt. In excessive circumstances, this could result in consuming problems resembling orthorexia or anorexia nervosa.
Moreover, radically limiting vitamins can have an effect on the steadiness of neurotransmitters within the mind, contributing to irritability and fatigue which, in flip, negatively affect emotional well-being.
Why are they so common?
Regardless of their dangers, mono diets proceed to achieve success, particularly on social media. Their attraction lies of their simplicity and the promise of fast outcomes with minimal effort. As well as, many of those diets are promoted by celebrities or influencers, giving them a false sense of credibility. Misinformation, aesthetic stress and a broader lack of dietary schooling are additionally contributing components.
The important thing takeaway is that single-food diets could also be efficient for fast and non permanent weight reduction, however they aren’t efficient in the long run, and are harmful if adopted for lengthy intervals of time. They supply no actual well being advantages, and might result in dietary deficiencies and main well being issues.
For these causes, they aren’t advisable, and shouldn’t be promoted as applicable types of weight management or well being enchancment. One of the simplest ways to achieve and keep a wholesome weight remains to be a balanced, different food regimen, accompanied by common bodily exercise and wholesome life-style habits.
Offered by
The Dialog
This text is republished from The Dialog underneath a Inventive Commons license. Learn the unique article.
Quotation:
Single-food ‘mono diets’: Are they efficient, pointless, or simply plain harmful? (2025, July 20)
retrieved 20 July 2025
from https://medicalxpress.com/information/2025-07-food-mono-diets-effective-pointless.html
This doc is topic to copyright. Aside from any honest dealing for the aim of personal examine or analysis, no
half could also be reproduced with out the written permission. The content material is supplied for info functions solely.
