With Senator Catherine Cortez Masto’s victory in Nevada, Democrats will retain Senate control next year, even if Republicans win a December run-off election in Georgia. While Tuesday’s election represented an unusually strong performance by a first-term president’s party, the individual showings of Senate candidates varied widely.
Arrows show how much counties voted more Republican or Democratic in the 2022 Senate races than in the 2020 presidential election.
Some Democrats who won improved on President Biden’s 2020 margins, while others did worse but still maintained their seats. Some eked out wins, while the Democratic candidates for other offices in their states cruised to victory. The reasons vary — some faced weaker opponents endorsed by Mr. Trump, while others ran in states where issues like democracy and abortion were particularly salient.
Margin shifts since 2020 were mixed in the most competitive states. Some winning Democrats outperformed Mr. Biden, particularly Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona, who defeated the Republican newcomer Blake Masters by 6 points as of Saturday. (That figure could change as more votes are counted.) In Wisconsin and North Carolina, winning Republicans slightly outperformed Mr. Trump, while the author J.D. Vance won Ohio by a smaller margin than the former president.
The most competitive states
+1.8 pts. Dem.
Hassan did better
than Biden
Mark Kelly (D) wins
+5.4 pts. Dem.
Kelly did better
than Biden
+3.2 pts. Dem.
Fetterman did better
than Biden
Runoff on Dec. 9
+0.7 pts. Dem.
Warnock did better
than Biden
Catherine Cortez Masto (D) wins
+1.7 pts. Rep.
Cortez Masto did worse
than Biden
+1.6 pts. Rep.
Johnson did better
than Trump
+2.3 pts. Rep.
Budd did better
than Trump
J.D. Vance (R) wins
+1.5 pts. Dem.
Vance did worse
than Trump
Senate races with winning margins of 10 points or less. Margins may change as the rest of the vote is counted in each state.
Some of the biggest shifts from 2020 were in solidly blue and red states. Democratic candidates in New York, Maryland and Connecticut won comfortably, but by much slimmer margins than Biden received.
Solid Democrat states
Brian Schatz (D) wins
+15.8 pts. Dem.
Schatz did better
than Biden
Peter Welch (D) wins
+4.8 pts. Dem.
Welch did better
than Biden
Chris Van Hollen (D) wins
+7.0 pts. Rep.
Van Hollen did worse
than Biden
+5.2 pts. Rep.
Blumenthal did worse
than Biden
Tammy Duckworth (D) wins
+3.4 pts. Rep.
Duckworth did worse
than Biden
Chuck Schumer (D) wins
+9.9 pts. Rep.
Schumer did worse
than Biden
Michael Bennet (D) wins
+0.2 pts. Rep.
Bennet did worse
than Biden
Margins may change as the rest of the vote is counted in each state. California, Oregon and Washington State are not shown because not enough of the vote has been reported to make comparisons.
While Republican Senate candidates in red states were more likely to improve upon Mr. Trump’s 2020 margins, they did lose some ground in a handful of states.
Solid Republican states
Charles E. Grassley (R) wins
+4.0 pts. Rep.
Grassley did better
than Trump
Eric Schmitt (R) wins
+2.1 pts. Dem.
Schmitt did worse
than Trump
Marco Rubio (R) wins
+13.1 pts. Rep.
Rubio did better
than Trump
Todd Young (R) wins
+4.7 pts. Rep.
Young did better
than Trump
Jerry Moran (R) wins
+8.7 pts. Rep.
Moran did better
than Trump
+2.4 pts. Dem.
Paul did worse
than Trump
+14.2 pts. Rep.
Scott did better
than Trump
+6.5 pts. Dem.
Mullin did worse
than Trump
Mike Crapo (R) wins
+1.1 pts. Rep.
Crapo did better
than Trump
James Lankford (R) wins
+0.9 pts. Dem.
Lankford did worse
than Trump
John Boozman (R) wins
+7.2 pts. Rep.
Boozman did better
than Trump
Katie Britt (R) wins
+10.3 pts. Rep.
Britt did better
than Trump
+17.3 pts. Rep.
Thune did better
than Trump
Margins may change as the rest of the vote is counted in each state. Alaska, Louisiana, North Dakota and Utah are not shown because the party breakdown of candidates in this election do not allow comparable margins to be calculated.
Comparisons to other statewide races
In several competitive states, voters split their tickets, selecting a Senate candidate from a different party than their choice for governor or secretary of state. New Hampshire Governor Chris Sununu, a Republican, won reelection by more than 15 points. But Senator Maggie Hassan, a Democrat, also won reelection, beating out Don Buldoc, a far-right candidate who has supported the false claim that the 2020 election was stolen.
R+6.6
Vance
R+25.6
DeWine
R+20.1
LaRose
D+9.2
Hassan
R+15.5
Sununu
D+0.9
Warnock
R+7.6
Kemp
R+5.0
Jones
R+9.3
Raffensperger
D+0.7
Cortez Masto
R+2.3
Lombardo
R+4.5
Anthony
D+1.5
Aguilar
D+5.7
Kelly
—
Not yet called
D+5.8
Fontes
R+1.0
Johnson
D+3.4
Evers
—
Not yet called
D+4.4
Fetterman
D+14.3
Shapiro
Competitive Senate races with winning margins of 10 points or less are shown. North Carolina is not included because it did not have elections for the other top statewide offices. Margins may change as the rest of the vote is counted in each state.
In Georgia, Senator Raphael Warnock, a Democrat, advanced to a runoff election against Herschel Walker, while the Republicans Brian Kemp, the governor, and Brad Raffensperger, the secretary of state, won by healthy margins. In Pennsylvania, John Fetterman won his Senate race, but his support lagged behind fellow Democrat and candidate for governor, Josh Shapiro.
